The Crack Wasn’t Caused by the Incident: How Engineers Identify Pre-Existing Fatigue Damage in Motor Vehicle Claims

Overturned truck with a traffic cone and the text: Did the incident cause the chassis crack? What forensic engineers look for to determine causation.

One of the most common scenarios in vehicle and mobile plant claims begins with a simple statement:

“Everything was fine until the incident happened.”

The insured reports hearing a bang, feeling the vehicle pull to one side, or discovering a cracked chassis after traversing a pothole, traffic island or unsealed road. The assumption is often that the reported event caused the damage.

However, forensic engineering investigations frequently demonstrate that the incident was part of a final stage of failure, not the cause of the damage.

Several recent ATTAR investigations involving various vehicle types identified fatigue cracking that existed long before the reported incident occurred. In each case, the final failure event brought the problem to attention, but the underlying damage had been developing over an extended period.

What Is Fatigue Cracking?

Fatigue cracking is a progressive failure mechanism that occurs when a component is subjected to repeated cyclic loading. Rather than failing suddenly, microscopic cracks initiate at areas of high stress concentration and gradually grow over thousands or even millions of load cycles.

Typical high stress points include:

  • Weld toes and weld roots
  • Rivet and bolt holes
  • Brackets and attachment points
  • Previous repair locations
  • Areas of localised impact damage
  • Sharp geometric transitions

As the fatigue crack grows, the remaining intact section becomes too small to carry the applied load, eventually resulting in sudden overload fracture. To an operator, the failure appears instantaneous. To an engineer, it often reveals a long history of damage progression.

The Evidence Engineers Look For

1. Beach Marks and Crack Progression Marks

One of the clearest indicators of fatigue is the presence of “beach marks” on a fracture surface.

These visible bands show the crack advancing incrementally over time. In a recent utility vehicle investigation, crack progression marks were present across approximately half of the cross-section of an axle before final overload failure occurred.

Other common fatigue crack initiation sites include chassis welds and cut-outs, and suspension attachments.

For claims professionals, the presence of beach marks is often one of the strongest indicators that the cracking pre-dated the reported incident, where fatigue cracks can also be attributed to under-design from the manufacturer, overloading of the vehicle, poorly thought out GVM upgrades, and more.

2. Corrosion, Fretting and Rubbing

Freshly fractured steel presents differently from a crack that has existed for weeks or months, where newly fractured metal can appear bright and shiny, although fresh metal will corrode rapidly in the presence of moisture, highlighting the need for careful storage post-failure.

Where crack faces have been moving against each other under service loading, engineers may identify:

  • Polished rubbing surfaces
  • Fretting wear
  • Surface oxidation
  • Corrosion products

3. Crack Location Matters

Fatigue cracks rarely occur randomly.

Instead, they almost always initiate in areas where stresses are concentrated.

Examples from recent investigations include:

  • Structural attachment holes and fastening points.
  • Weld roots associated with suspension or axle mounting brackets.
  • Welded structural members and chassis attachments.

When a crack initiates at a recognised stress concentration, it often points towards progressive loading rather than a one-off impact event.

4. Evidence of Previous Repairs

Previous repairs can be highly significant.

In one chassis investigation, ATTAR identified that a previous repair initiated a fatigue failure. The evidence suggested the repair failure occurred first, increasing loading on the opposite side of the structure and contributing to further fatigue cracking elsewhere.

For assessors, evidence of historical repairs should immediately prompt questions about:

  • Whether an earlier defect existed
  • The adequacy of the repair
  • Whether the current damage represents a continuation of a prior condition

5. Absence of Impact Evidence

When an insured reports that a pothole, kerb strike or other event caused a structural failure, the engineer will typically search for impact evidence.

This may include:

  • Gouges
  • Scrapes
  • Plastic deformation
  • Denting
  • Localised material displacement

Although evidence may suggest a high stress event, the absence of evidence does not mean an event did not occur.

Why This Matters for Claims

Understanding whether a component failed because of a sudden event or because of pre-existing fatigue damage can materially affect:

  • Causation assessments
  • Coverage decisions
  • Repair scope
  • Recovery opportunities
  • Insured’s expectations

The event reported by the insured and the underlying cause of damage are not necessarily the same thing.

A kerb strike may trigger final failure.

A pothole may expose an existing crack.

The engineering question is not merely:

“What happened when it failed?”

It is:

“What caused the component to reach the point where failure became inevitable?”

Key Takeaway for Assessors

When dealing with structural or component failures, consider whether the reported incident may have been the trigger rather than the root cause.

Indicators that specialist engineering input may be warranted include:

  • Cracks radiating from welds or holes.
  • Evidence of previous repairs.
  • Failures with no obvious impact damage.
  • Components fracturing under apparently normal operation.
  • Damage developing in older or heavily utilised vehicles.

Understanding the distinction between a sudden event and progressive deterioration can significantly reduce uncertainty and help ensure claims decisions are based on the actual cause of loss rather than the circumstances in which the loss became apparent.

For further information, please contact ATTAR at  info@attar.com.au or call 1300 139 155.

Read Also
Wet Barefoot Inclining Platform Test ATTAR

Inclining Platform Testing Methods

Inclining Platform Testing Methods Wet Barefoot or Oil-Wet Tests? Inclining platform testing methods, as detailed in the Australian Standards for Slip Resistance (AS 4586), can

Read More »